Listen to this Post
A Misleading Trend: Why You Shouldn’t Trust Monthly Market Share Headlines
Every month like clockwork, a wave of articles flood tech sites, citing Statcounter’s latest Windows market share data. The narrative is almost always the same: Windows 11 is spiking, Windows 10 is collapsing, and the desktop OS world is suddenly shifting. But beneath the dramatic headlines and breathless commentary lies a problem—a fundamental misunderstanding of what this data actually represents.
Statcounter’s latest global chart, covering July 2024 through June 2025, shows a steep decline in Windows 10 usage and a corresponding rise in Windows 11. Many writers and analysts jump to conclude that Windows 11 has finally caught up to its predecessor, citing marginal differences as major milestones. But the truth is more complicated—and far less dramatic.
At its core, Statcounter collects data from a shrinking pool of websites that have chosen to install its tracking pixel. The data is based on pageviews, not devices or users. If one Windows 10 user browses ten pages and a Windows 11 user browses five, the data would show Windows 10 as twice as “popular.” That’s not how real-world market share works. Worse still, tracking protection in modern browsers (especially Edge with strict settings) can block Statcounter’s data collection entirely, making their data even more incomplete.
A deeper analysis of US-only data from Statcounter (January 2022 to June 2025) shows more stable trends: a steady decline in Windows 10 and a gradual increase in Windows 11 traffic. No sudden spikes. No wild surges. Just a consistent trend line with the usual noise typical in small sample data. What pundits see as surges are often statistical illusions—anomalies that disappear when viewed in broader context or with polynomial trendlines that smooth out monthly variation.
Another issue: Statcounter’s influence is shrinking. From 3 million sites in 2009 to just 1.5 million by 2022, and only 0.4% of websites using it in 2025, according to W3Techs. Most popular sites like Google, Facebook, and Wikipedia don’t use it. So what we’re seeing is a tiny slice of web activity, filtered through a shrinking, arguably skewed, lens.
The decline in Windows 10 traffic and rise of Windows 11 is happening, yes. But the real story is slower, less exciting, and more influenced by broader trends like end-of-support deadlines and upgrade eligibility. Microsoft’s own telemetry—data it doesn’t make public—would be the true gold standard. Until then, media outlets relying solely on Statcounter are building castles in the statistical sand.
What Undercode Say:
The narrative around Windows 11’s meteoric rise needs a critical eye. The dramatic headlines you’re seeing? They’re not grounded in solid data, but in the excitement of month-to-month noise presented as trend. Here’s why we need to stop treating Statcounter reports like gospel:
1. Pageviews ≠ Market Share
Statcounter tracks pageviews from a decreasing number of websites. It does not count actual users, devices, or installations. A single Windows 10 user reading more pages than a Windows 11 user could skew the numbers.
2. Sample Bias
Most large websites don’t use Statcounter. Its data comes from a niche, shrinking segment of the internet. It’s like polling voters by only calling landlines in rural areas—your sample doesn’t represent the whole.
3. Blocked Trackers
Modern browsers often block Statcounter’s trackers entirely, especially under strict privacy settings. This leads to undercounting users on certain OS/browser combinations.
4. Short-Term Spikes Are Misleading
Looking at just one or two months of data introduces misleading volatility. Broader trend analysis using polynomial regression gives a much clearer picture: Windows 11 is slowly gaining ground, not skyrocketing.
5.
With less than 0.5% of websites using it, Statcounter’s reach is too narrow to paint a reliable global picture. Google Analytics and Microsoft telemetry have far better datasets—though they aren’t public.
6. Timing Is Everything
As Windows 10 support nears its October 2025 end, gradual migration to Windows 11 is inevitable. But the “surge” likely reflects ongoing transitions—not sudden user behavior shifts.
7. Media Overreach
Writers and analysts love a good horse race. But citing “less than a 1% gap” between OS versions as evidence of a major shift ignores statistical margins of error. That’s not journalism—it’s speculation.
8.
The free updates Microsoft now offers for certain Windows 10 users dampen urgency to upgrade. Many businesses and individuals are in a holding pattern, waiting until the final quarter of 2025.
9. Enterprise Users Are Invisible
Most corporate machines don’t generate measurable pageviews. They may block tracking scripts, use internal networks, or simply operate in environments where usage data isn’t collected.
10. OS Telemetry ≠ Web Analytics
Web traffic and OS adoption are not the same. The device you use to browse doesn’t represent how many devices globally are running each version. Confusing the two creates flawed conclusions.
So where does that leave us? With nuance. Windows 11 adoption is real but slow, propelled by necessity more than desire. If you’re a journalist or analyst, be skeptical of web analytics as a substitute for telemetry. If you’re a reader, understand that these numbers are shaped as much by methodology as by reality.
🔍 Fact Checker Results
✅ Statcounter tracks pageviews, not devices—confirmed by Statcounter documentation.
✅ Less than 0.5% of websites use Statcounter today—verified via W3Techs.
❌ Claim that Windows 11 “caught up” to Windows 10 in user base is unproven and based on flawed metrics.
📊 Prediction
As the October 2025 deadline for Windows 10 support approaches, expect to see a gradual uptick in Windows 11 usage, but not a dramatic crossover. Enterprise users and hardware-ineligible PCs will delay that shift. True parity may not arrive until mid-to-late 2026. Meanwhile, headlines about monthly “surges” in usage will continue to crop up—but they’ll be more noise than news.
References:
Reported By: www.zdnet.com
Extra Source Hub:
https://www.github.com
Wikipedia
OpenAi & Undercode AI
Image Source:
Unsplash
Undercode AI DI v2
