Listen to this Post
In a world where national identity is closely tied to global perception, a thought-provoking comment by Indian investment banker Sarthak Ahuja has stirred conversation across South Asian communities online. Ahuja recently took to LinkedIn to share a personal encounter in New York, where he claimed that a hotel staffer, seemingly of Pakistani origin, identified himself as being from “Gujarat”—a statement Ahuja interpreted as an attempt to pass off as Indian.
According to Ahuja, this wasn’t an isolated incident. He’s noticed a pattern during his international travels: Pakistanis abroad sometimes hide their nationality, either to avoid uncomfortable questions or to sidestep the stigma they feel is attached to their homeland. His post goes beyond mere observation—it questions the deep-rooted insecurities tied to national branding and the way people respond to international stereotypes.
This article takes a closer look at what Ahuja said, the broader implications of his statements, and offers an analytical perspective on the reality of diasporic identity and the challenges faced by Pakistani nationals abroad.
the Incident and Ahuja’s Observations (Approx. )
Sarthak Ahuja, an Indian investment banker, shared a viral LinkedIn post recounting an experience in New York.
He claims a hotel staffer, possibly of Pakistani origin, said he was from “Gujarat,” a name associated more commonly with India, though also a city in Pakistan.
Ahuja interpreted this as a strategic identity shift to avoid the stigma attached to Pakistan’s global image.
He argues that this behavior isn’t rare—he’s encountered it in Canada, the UK, Europe, and the US.
According to Ahuja, many Pakistanis abroad feel embarrassed about their nationality and may adopt an Indian identity for smoother social interactions or job prospects.
He claims this shift is not due to hostility but rather due to the perceived superior image of India globally.
He points out that numerous “Indian” restaurants in the UK are actually run by Pakistanis, yet marketed as Indian establishments.
Ahuja emphasized he holds no hostility toward Pakistani civilians but believes this dynamic underscores how beneficial India’s global brand has been—even to those across the border.
He concludes with a patriotic note, expressing condolences for Indian war casualties and ending with the slogan “Jai Hind.”
His post received significant attention, drawing both support and criticism, as it touches on sensitive identity and national pride issues.
What Undercode Say: A Deep-Dive into the Dynamics of Diasporic Identity (Approx. 40 Lines)
The situation outlined by Ahuja taps into a complex intersection of national identity, perception politics, and survival strategies in the diaspora. It’s essential to examine this through both sociological and geopolitical lenses.
1. National Branding & Global Perception
India and Pakistan, despite shared histories and cultures, have diverged dramatically in their global branding. India, with its IT boom, Bollywood, and diaspora diplomacy, enjoys a relatively favorable image in the West. Pakistan, meanwhile, often struggles under the weight of negative media narratives—mostly tied to terrorism, political instability, or economic hardship. For many, identifying as Indian offers social ease and career convenience.
2. The Survival Strategy of Immigrants
Immigrants, especially those working service jobs or running small businesses, often prioritize acceptance and adaptability over authenticity. If identifying as Indian means fewer awkward questions or increased customer trust, many might find it a practical compromise rather than a betrayal of identity.
3. Cultural Proximity Fuels Misidentification
Indian and Pakistani cultures, especially for non-South Asians, are nearly indistinguishable. Language, food, attire, and even facial features overlap significantly. This makes it easier for Pakistanis to blend into the Indian identity abroad without immediately raising eyebrows.
4. Restaurant Industry Realities
In the UK especially, the term “Indian restaurant” is almost a genre of its own. Many Pakistani or Bangladeshi restaurateurs adopt this branding for commercial viability. The label “Pakistani restaurant” might not draw the same attention or appeal to the mainstream, thus it becomes a business decision rather than one rooted in self-rejection.
5. Identity and Embarrassment
To say Pakistanis are “embarrassed” of their identity may be an oversimplification. Rather, many feel frustrated by how their country is portrayed internationally. While some might internalize this, others simply adopt a temporary facade for smoother navigation in foreign cultures.
6. Nationalistic Undertones
Ahuja’s post, while claiming neutrality, does carry a nationalistic tone. Ending with “Jai Hind” and referencing war casualties brings in emotions that risk blurring objective observation with patriotic sentiment. It’s worth noting that identity politics, especially in South Asia, are often emotionally charged and need nuanced handling.
7. Generalization vs. Lived Experience
While Ahuja’s anecdote may be genuine, generalizing it across the global Pakistani diaspora is problematic. There are many proud Pakistani professionals, entrepreneurs, and students abroad who openly celebrate their heritage. Like any population, behaviors vary across class, generation, and personal history.
8. The Need for Constructive Dialogue
Instead of framing such identity shifts as shameful or opportunistic, perhaps the conversation should focus on why some individuals feel the need to mask their origin. Improving global perceptions starts with internal reform and international diplomacy—not blaming the individuals trying to adapt.
Fact Checker Results
There is indeed a city named Gujarat in Pakistan, as well as a state called Gujarat in India.
Many Indian-branded restaurants in the UK are owned by Pakistanis or Bangladeshis.
Anecdotal evidence of Pakistanis identifying as Indians abroad exists, but there’s no large-scale empirical study validating how widespread the behavior is.
Prediction
As geopolitical narratives continue to evolve, national identity among South Asian diaspora will remain fluid and complex. With India’s rising soft power and Pakistan’s ongoing image struggles, we can expect more such identity blending in contexts where social mobility is key. However, as global audiences become more culturally aware, the demand for authentic representation might push diasporic communities to reclaim and redefine their roots—whether Pakistani, Indian, or otherwise.
References:
Reported By: timesofindia.indiatimes.com
Extra Source Hub:
https://www.quora.com
Wikipedia
Undercode AI
Image Source:
Unsplash
Undercode AI DI v2
